Messiah, HWV 56
At a Glance
-
Composed
1741 -
Length
c. 135 minutes -
Orchestration
2 oboes, 2 bassoons, 2 trumpets, timpani, continuo, and strings, with soprano, alto, tenor, and bass soloists and chorus -
First Los Angeles Philharmonic Performance
December 19, 1937, Richard Lert conducting, with soprano Wynne Davis, contralto Elizabeth Klein, tenor Russell Horton, bass Sten Englund, and the Los Angeles Oratorio Society
About this Piece
One of the most intriguing aspects of tonight’s performance of Messiah is the musical perspective Emmanuelle Haïm and Le Concert d’Astrée bring to a work so closely identified with the English-speaking world. The French ensemble, comprising a period-instrument orchestra and chorus, has cultivated a vividly theatrical approach to Baroque opera and vocal music under Haïm, its founder and LA Phil Artist Collaborator since 2024, whose experience spans both French and English traditions.
Richard Wilberforce, Le Concert d’Astrée’s choir master, explains that the ensemble draws on different singers according to the needs of the repertoire. For Messiah, it has assembled 24 British choristers, most of them based in London, bringing their familiarity with the language to an interpretation shaped by what Wilberforce calls Haïm’s distinctive “French touch.”
Handel’s own place in English musical culture was somewhat paradoxical. A German immigrant celebrated in London as a national treasure, he remained thoroughly cosmopolitan in his musical outlook, having absorbed the diverse styles of Rome, Florence, Naples, and Venice during his formative years in Italy. Messiah combines German contrapuntal craftsmanship and the English anthem tradition with Italianate lyricism and gestures of French grandeur.
Haïm’s approach to ornamentation will be among the most immediately audible features of her interpretation. Her choruses incorporate trills and other embellishments more freely than listeners may be accustomed to hearing in performances of Messiah. Wilberforce also points to notes inégales, a French Baroque practice of inflecting written quavers rather than singing or playing them strictly evenly. It’s “not quite swung,” yet has something of the character of a Baroque version of swing. The music acquires “a bit more of a groove.” Haïm, he adds, has a remarkable feeling for “the swing and the dance of this music.”
Grant Gershon, Artistic Director of the Los Angeles Master Chorale, first worked with Haïm on a production of Don Giovanni in Aix-en-Provence in 1998, but this is the first opportunity they have had to collaborate since. As an example of Haïm’s approach to ornamentation, he points to the first chorus, “And the glory of the Lord,” where passing tones, appoggiaturas, and other ornaments give the melodic lines additional lift and bounce. This is the Master Chorale’s first Messiah with period instruments. Although many of its singers are themselves early-music specialists, the ensemble is adapting its accustomed approach to Haïm’s particular performance practices.
Haïm’s operatic experience also shapes her conception of individual voices. One example is her established collaboration with countertenor Carlo Vistoli, whose rich timbre and strong lower register, Wilberforce notes, are particularly well suited to Handel’s alto writing. That same ear for individual vocal character informs Haïm’s approach to the chorus: She favors “a group of singers made up of almost soloists”—vocal personalities capable of delivering arias in their own right, each with a distinctive communicative quality, yet able to come together in a cohesive ensemble. Wilberforce contrasts this sound with the English choral tradition exemplified by the Choir of King’s College, Cambridge. Haïm welcomes warmth and expressive vibrato, including from the sopranos, while seeking a unified ensemble sound.
Handel, too, was above all a man of the theater. His gift for shaping mood to suit a given situation had established his reputation as a composer of Italian opera. By the early 1740s, however, the fickle London public’s changing tastes, compounded by the financial pressures of operatic production, had compelled him to reinvent himself through the English-language oratorio. Handel had helped develop the genre by bringing the expressive resources of Italian music drama together with the English choral tradition. It offered the moral uplift of sacred subject matter—sweetened with the entertainment value of opera but without the expense of sets and costumes.
Completed in just 24 days in 1741, Messiah represented an unusually bold experiment. The librettist, Charles Jennens, was a wealthy, deeply devout patron who was alienated from contemporary English politics. He had previously collaborated with Handel on Saul (1739) and L’Allegro, il Penseroso ed il Moderato (1740) and had likely compiled the biblical text for Israel in Egypt (1739). For Messiah, he fashioned an ambitious biblical collage, juxtaposing passages from the Old and New Testaments to evoke the central narrative of Christian redemption. Christ himself never appears as a singing character. His story is instead distributed among the soloists and chorus. At moments, the chorus assumes sharply polarized identities, from the angels proclaiming “Glory to God” to the jeering crowd mocking the crucified Jesus in “He trusted in God.”
Handel’s musical imagination transforms this indirect narrative into an extraordinarily varied drama. Especially striking is the prominence of the chorus, which gives collective voice to prophecy, human frailty, and the ultimate triumph over sin and death. Handel draws on an encyclopedic range of choral textures and expressive gestures, interspersing these with individually characterized arias. In Part I alone, the music encompasses the fathomless darkness of a world awaiting a savior, the tranquil oasis of the Pastoral Symphony (the purely instrumental Pifa, evoking the music of peaceful shepherds), and the exuberance of “Rejoice greatly.” Later, the wandering choral lines of “All we like sheep” vividly portray our waywardness before a sudden turn to the minor mode reveals its darker consequences.
The orchestration is admirably economical, yet Handel deploys its resources with an acute sense of dramatic pacing. He withholds the trumpets until “Glory to God” in Part I, then reserves them again until the great “Hallelujah” chorus concluding Part II—which celebrates the triumph of redemption rather than the moment of Christ’s resurrection. The final part brings the journey to its culmination with “The trumpet shall sound,” the majestic “Worthy is the Lamb,” and the great contrapuntal “Amen,” in which the voices intertwine like strands of light.
Introduced to acclaim in Dublin in April 1742, Messiah encountered resistance when Handel brought it to London, where the presentation of sacred texts in a theater was considered objectionable by some. But annual charity performances for the Foundling Hospital, beginning in 1750, soon helped establish its enduring popularity. Handel’s own presentations of Messiah took place around Easter; the oratorio’s now-familiar association with Christmas emerged only after his lifetime.
Handel himself repeatedly revised the score to suit different singers and performing circumstances. Later generations continued to refashion the work, most famously Mozart, who prepared an arrangement for Viennese audiences in 1789. Haïm’s interpretation is essentially uncut, retaining numbers in Parts II and III that are frequently omitted in performance.
The combined chorus of 40 singers—24 from Le Concert d’Astrée and 16 from the Master Chorale—reflects the needs of this artistic partnership rather than an attempt to reconstruct the forces of a particular performance in Handel’s lifetime. The enormous choruses favored during the 19th century could obscure the intricate counterpoint of Handel’s fugues. Here, the ensemble can preserve that clarity while lending greater monumentality to the grandest numbers, allowing the voices to “really shine against the trumpets and the timpani,” as Wilberforce puts it.
Haïm’s extraordinary attention to text shapes her choices of tempo. She spends months studying how the words are constructed and how their meaning can emerge in performance. Decades of experience with Handel’s operas and oratorios have also given Haïm an instinctive feeling for the music’s pacing, according to Wilberforce. This sense of dramatic continuity also governs the relationship between soloists and chorus. Discussing her 2014 recording of Messiah with Le Concert d’Astrée, Haïm herself described the relationship this way: “It’s an assembly, into which a soloist enters and the crowd responds. But it’s a collective gesture.”
—Thomas May