Piano Concerto No. 2 in B-flat major, Op. 19
Allegro con brio
Adagio
Rondo: Molto allegro
At a Glance
-
Composed
1787-89 (rev. 1798, 1801) -
Length
c. 28 minutes -
Orchestration
flute, 2 oboes, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, strings, and solo piano -
First Los Angeles Philharmonic Performance
February 27, 1937, Otto Klemperer conducting, with Webster Aitken, soloist
About this Piece
During much of his first decade in his adopted Vienna, Beethoven was known primarily as one of the city’s most accomplished and popular pianists. Having settled there permanently in November 1792, he soon became a regular fixture in the salons of the nobility. Vienna’s musical upper crust quickly recognized his immense abilities and was charmed by his country-bumpkin accent and awkward, self-conscious manners. At an early soirée at the home of Prince Lichnowsky, the always touchy composer was angered because the Prince’s guests continued to talk while he was playing. “I shall not perform before such swine,” he snarled, slamming the lid of the fortepiano to the secret amusement of the tolerant nobleman.
In March 1795, Beethoven took the decisive step of making his initial public appearance in Vienna at a pair of charity concerts at the city’s Burgtheater. At the first of these, on March 25, he introduced the B-flat-major Concerto he had completed earlier in the month. (Although there were rumored to be two earlier concertos from the Bonn period, only the piano part of an E-flat-major concerto survives, while a D-major concerto, thought to be Beethoven’s throughout most of the 19th century, was eventually shown to be the work of the Bohemian composer Johann Josef Rösler.)
Though it was written before the C-major Concerto of 1798, the B-flat Concerto was published much later. As Beethoven made the bulk of his living as a performing virtuoso in an age innocent of the laws of copyright, it was his custom never to write down the solo part until he had played a new work as often as the market would bear.
An even more important reason for delaying publication was his dissatisfaction with the concerto’s final movement. For a performance in Prague three years after the Viennese premiere, he supplied a completely new Rondo-finale, the one that now appears in the published score. With a flash of the arrogant humility for which he was already becoming well known, Beethoven characterized the work as “a pianoforte concerto which I really do not give out for one of my best,” but quickly added, “Nonetheless, it will not disgrace you to print it.”
The opening movement, Allegro con brio, begins with a proud unison orchestral flourish that leads immediately to the vigorous principal theme assigned to the first violins. As in many of the Mozart concertos, the piano enters playing a variant of the movement’s lyrical second subject; only after a brief orchestral interruption does it finally attack the principal theme in earnest. An extended dialogue, made up of fragments of both themes and requiring considerable virtuosity from the soloist, serves as the development section. The movement ends dutifully with a conventional recapitulation, complete with the obligatory cadenza.
The heart of the concerto is a flowing Adagio based on one of the young Beethoven’s most inspired inventions: a serenely pensive melody that offers an astonishing foretaste of the great adagio theme of the Ninth Symphony. Announced quietly by the violins, the tune is modified and embellished by both soloist and orchestra until it returns, all but inaudibly, to bring the movement to a close.
The breezy finale, a Haydnesque amalgam of sonata and rondo form, is based on a jaunty, unbuttoned ditty, which eventually returns three times; the contrasting material cleverly toys with the syncopated character of the principal theme. The irrepressible rondo figure eventually returns to conclude this, the first of Beethoven’s completed orchestral scores.
—Jim Svejda